I had grand plans for more colors and shapes, but they ultimately boiled down to Spider-Men Peter and Miles, and the number four. I couldn’t find time to make these farther in advance, so I made them the night before. I like to bake right up until the last minute because I think a whole day ahead spoils the baked goods – they just don’t taste as fresh.
I’ve decorated sugar cookies a few times. My favorites being Halloween 2019 and 2020 and Christmas. I need to make something once or twice before I get the hang of it. I like how these Spider-Man cookies came out, but I don’t love them. They could definitely be better. However, for my first attempt, I surprised myself.
Decorating the Spider-Man Sugar Cookies
When I started to plan out the cookies, I made these drawings to help guide me. I wanted to figure out what cookies I would make and what colors to use. Due to my limited tools, I need to plan out which colors to mix first. I only have so many bottles and bags!
Here are those plans:
I wanted to do more with the number four cookies, but I left them bare and with just a royal icing outline. I knew there were some people who don’t like royal icing and would appreciate just the cookie. I also stuck to three colors: white, red, and black. I wanted to use blue, but again, this was at 10pm the night before.
So I made the royal icing and mixed the colors. I followed my plans and started with red, then black, and then white. That seemed to work out for the most part. At one point a chunk of icing got stuck in the icing tip and the bottle opened and exploded all over my kitchen. I knew I needed to wrap up at that point.
My only takeaways are:
- Get better at making flood icing. This was way too watery…and I was rushing.
- Find better gel colors. The red gel color tasted really off, almost bitter.
- More webs on the costumes. I needed to do a better job at doing more web lines on the costumes. The one Peter Parker cookie looks great. More lines.
- This is still the best sugar cookie recipe to use – with or without icing.
Thank you for all the advice you left me on Instagram. I will try to switch up my technique!
